Evolutionary Ecology

Understanding when species diversification and phenotypic evolution are coupled remains a central challenge in macroevolution. Such coupling may depend on the traits considered, phenotypic integration, or the geographic context in which diversification occurs. Here, we investigate these relationships in Ithomiini, a diverse Neotropical butterfly tribe whose diversification is strongly associated with the Andes-Amazonia system. We quantified forewing and hindwing size and shape for 1,618 individuals representing 291 species using geometric morphometrics, and combined these data with phylogenetic comparative methods, diversification-rate estimates, and spatial analyses of species distributions. Evolutionary rate shifts were largely trait- and wing-specific, indicating limited coupling between forewing and hindwing evolution. Across the phylogeny, wing size evolution and extant wing size were not associated with species diversification, nor was hindwing shape evolution. By contrast, forewing shape evolutionary rates showed a positive association with diversification. Spatial analyses revealed that this coupling was geographically concentrated in the Andes, where high diversification rates coincided with elevated forewing size and shape diversity and increased forewing evolutionary rates. Hindwing diversity, by contrast, more closely tracked phylogenetic diversity and showed weaker or opposing relationships with diversification. Our results show that diversification and phenotypic evolution in Ithomiini are neither generally coupled nor fully independent, but linked in trait-specific and geographically structured ways. More broadly, they highlight the need to decompose complex phenotypes and integrate spatial context when testing macroevolutionary coupling.

Sperm competition can occur when sperm from two or more males compete for fertilization of a batch of eggs. While it has been extensively studied in internal fertilizers, it remains poorly under-stood in external fertilizers. To investigate how sperm competition affects fertilization under sperm limitation, we conducted controlled experiments on two sea urchin species: Paracentrotus lividus and Dendraster excentricus. Eggs from a single female were exposed to sperm from three individ-ual males separately (non-competitive treatment) or to a pooled sample from three males (competi-tive treatment). We measured fertilization success as proportion of eggs fertilized after two hours and assessed sperm motility as percentage of motile sperm and curvilinear velocity. For P. lividus , we estimated the sperm concentrations where fertilization success was 50% of maximum observed fertilization success (F50), and the fertilization efficiency of the sperm (Fe), i.e. the likelihood that a sperm - egg encounter results in a fertilizing contact, using the fertilization kinetics model of Styan (1998). For D. excentricus, fertilization success was measured at a sperm concentration expected to produce 50% fertilization success. Sperm competition reduced fertilization success and increased F50 compared to non-competitive treatments, suggesting antagonistic effects that may compromise fertilization under sperm-limited conditions in external fertilizers.

Species interactions shape ecological dynamics, but adaptation to one interaction can trade off with others. Experiments that measure such evolved fitness changes across multiple interactions remain rare. We used experimental evolution to test whether recent selection under one ecological interaction changes fitness under other interactions in a fly-parasitoid system. We evolved a genetically diverse Drosophila melanogaster population for 15-17 generations under three regimes: benign conditions (control), high intraspecific competition, and infection by the parasitoid wasp Leptopilina boulardi. We then measured fly fitness (egg-to-adult survival and subsequent reproduction) under benign conditions, high intraspecific competition, and infection by three other parasitoid species and an additional conspecific L. boulardi strain. Selection history strongly influenced fitness across interactions. Populations maintained under high larval density showed reduced survival under infection by L. boulardi and L. victoriae, indicating a trade-off between past selection for competition and defence against some parasitoids. Populations evolved under parasitoid infection by L. boulardi showed increased resistance to a conspecific strain but reduced fitness when infected by another species, L. heterotoma. Our results show that rapid evolution in response to a single interaction can reshape multiple ecological interactions through fitness trade-offs, highlighting how recent evolutionary history may influence community dynamics and invasion susceptibility.

Defended prey are often thought to rely on conspicuous warning signals to distinguish themselves from undefended prey, facilitating predator learning and avoidance. Yet many chemically defended organisms are inconspicuous and difficult to distinguish from palatable prey, raising a fundamental question: how do predators avoid defended prey when prey themselves provide little or no reliable signals of defense? We tested whether host plants can function as indirect indicators of prey defense using Carolina wrens (Thryothorus ludovicianus), chemically defended Eumaeus atala larvae, undefended Galleria mellonella larvae, and two distinct plant species. Defended and undefended prey were experimentally made to appear visually identical, forcing predators to rely on host-plant associations as the only available source of information. Wrens rapidly altered both search behavior and attack decisions according to plant identity. Mechanistic attack models incorporating predator discrimination between defended and undefended prey were strongly favored when plants were present, with defended prey experiencing substantially lower attack risk than undefended prey. When plants were removed, support for discrimination weakened and attacks on both prey types increased. Spatial autocorrelation of host plants further shaped predator behavior, with strongly clustered plants hosting defended prey receiving disproportionately fewer visits. Together, these results suggest host plants can function as ecologically meaningful cues of prey defense, influencing both predator search patterns and attack decisions. More broadly, our findings suggest warning systems may extend beyond prey phenotype alone, and that ecological context (including host-plant identity and spatial structure) may contribute to the evolution and maintenance of aposematism.

A longstanding question in evolution is if similar morphologies shared by distantly related organisms facing similar environmental pressures belie similar functions. The carnivorous pitcher form has evolved in three distinct plant lineages and encompasses a suite of convergent morphological traits, providing a natural experiment to test hypothesized links between morphology and function. Multiple pitcher plant species possess fenestrations (i.e., small windows) that let light pass through the pitcher leaf. While research on one species, Nepenthes aristolochioides, demonstrates that fenestrations manipulate light to create false exits and increase prey capture, whether this convergent morphology serves this convergent function in other pitcher species remains unresolved. We explored the function of fenestrations in two additional species of pitcher plants, Nepenthes klossii and Cephalotus follicularis, where the morphology and function of fenestration were previously unexplored. We inspected micromorphology of pitcher structure, conducted an insect bioassay with live plants to test for links between morphology and function, and quantified traits associated with light manipulation from herbarium specimens. Both species exhibited fenestration and related pitcher morphology similar to N. aristolochioides. Yet our experiments did not reveal a significant effect of light passing through fenestrations on fly capture for these two species. Key differences between these species and the previously investigated species may be the presence of wax crystals and the absence of viscoelastic fluid. While future studies may uncover weak to moderate light manipulation function not detected in our study, our data do not support convergent function in these distantly related, morphologically similar species.

Animal colouration evolves under multiple, often conflicting, selective pressures. Conspicuous, non-aposematic colour-patterns that enhance conspecific communication may simultaneously increase detectability by predators. Such trade-offs can be resolved by optimising colour-patterns to match the perceptual abilities of different receivers. We tested whether dorsal colour-patterns of the Lusitanian wall lizard (Podarcis lusitanicus) are optimised for ecologically relevant receivers across relevant viewing distances, while accounting for the visual acuity of conspecifics and predators. Conspecifics and snakes detected chromatic information at shorter distances, whereas achromatic and luminance information were detected at longer distances. Birds showed a uniform decline in detectability across the colour-pattern components with increasing viewing distance. Larger males retained high chromatic detectability across all receivers despite the general distance-related decline, whereas females and smaller individuals exhibited less salient colour patterns, consistent with predator avoidance strategy. Our results show that lizards resolve the trade-off between conspecific communication and predator detection through distance-dependent colour-pattern perceptibility across receivers. This resolution breaks down in large males, for whom the benefits of salient chromatic patterns for intraspecific communication may outweigh increased detectability to predators.

Data on the shape of a group of organisms can be conceptualized as forming a point cloud in the multivariate space of measurement. This is literally true for traditional linear measures, while in a geometric morphometric context the cloud resides in Kendalls shape space, tangent to the true shape space. Regardless of the method of construction, the topology of this point cloud, or phenotypic (hyper)ellipse, is a beguiling target for evolutionary analysis. Reordination of the axes will not change the geometry of this phenotypic ellipse, and the notion that its geometry carries a meaningful biological signal is an old idea; but the character of this signal is often elusive. This paper explores the application of the most commonly used parameter designed to summarize differences in phenotypic ellipse geometry (relative eigenvalue variance, or Vrel), and demonstrates that it is incapable of differentiating between several plausible ways in which phenotypic ellipse geometry might differ among species, because it confounds three separate parameters necessary to describe the ellipse. Two example data sets are analyzed to illustrate variability in phenotypic ellipse geometry and draw conclusions about observed differences. The first case compares wolves to domestic dogs, and replicates previous findings of much greater variance yet tighter integration in dogs. This calls into question the simple model of a single peak in the fitness landscape of dogs. The second example comprises geometric morphometric landmarks from the jaws of a clade of sigmodontine rodents, and allows comparison of ellipse geometry in a phylogenetically controlled setting with qualitative ecological categories. Three parameters are found to vary in concert along a grade of most to least ecologically specialized: the phenotypic variance, the effective rank (dimensionality), and the degree of covariance (Vrel and related metrics). Use of all three of these quantities to characterize the geometry of the phenotypic ellipse is advocated, as all are necessary to characterize how variance is distributed in the ellipse in different taxa. The phenotypic ellipse geometries illustrated here appear to reflect something of the geometry of the adaptive peak upon which each taxon sits; or that they represent (aspects of) the mapping function of adaptive peak to phenotypic ellipse, in ways first predicted by Simpson in the twentieth century.

The evolutionary patterns of trait diversification provide insights into the function of the trait. Early burst of trait evolution is often associated with adaptive radiation, rapidly diversifying the trait in response to vacant niches followed by the slowdown of the diversification with niche filling, whereas late burst is more likely to be associated with sexual selection, possibly contributing to reproductive barriers between closely related species. Here, we studied the diversification of tail fork depth through time in hirundines to infer its function, which remains unclear due to the competing two alternative hypotheses: the sexual selection hypothesis, which is a classic explanation of deeply forked tails, proposed that this trait has evolved via sexual selection, which was then challenged by the viability selection hypothesis, which proposed that deeply forked tails have mainly evolved via viability selection for enhancing aerodynamic performance during aerial foraging on large prey. We found a late burst of tail fork depth, but not of bill length, i.e., an index of prey size. The observed pattern is consistent with the sexual selection hypothesis but not with the viability selection hypothesis.

Floral plantings can either concentrate bees or export them to adjacent crops, yet the ecological conditions influencing these outcomes remain unclear. Here, we develop a mathematical model as proof of concept for our previous integrative hypothesis: concentrator and exporter outcomes can arise as alternative, context-dependent outcomes of the same underlying resource-selection process. Using bees as a model and focusing specifically on spillover from floral plantings to crops, we identified resource-specific thresholds separating concentration- and export-favoring conditions. Our model translates differences in relative patch attractiveness into context-dependent concentration and export outcomes and generates resource-specific, testable predictions about the conditions favoring pollinator movement into crops. In our simulations, the concentrator-exporter transition occurred at a lower flowering-intensity contrast than at pollen or nectar contrasts, which suggests that flowering intensity may provide an initial cue for bee movement, whereas nectar and pollen rewards refine or sustain bee responses once crops are perceived as attractive. Spillover thresholds differed among resource contrasts, whereas response steepness varied across bee-trait and community scenarios. Under the model's trait-sensitivity formulation, predicted spillover probability responded more strongly to flowering contrast for specialists than for generalists; colony size amplified this response, whereas bee richness dampened it. Together, these patterns show how flowering and resource contrasts interact with bee traits and community context to shape predicted spillover. Our results confirm that the concentrator and exporter hypotheses can be understood as context-dependent outcomes of the same ecological process rather than as mutually exclusive alternatives. Experimental tests of the predicted thresholds conducted in the field could reveal when and where floral plantings are most likely to promote bee spillover to crops, potentially supporting crop pollination.

Animal personality is the expression of consistent among-individual variation in a behavioural trait across time and context. The application of this theory to behavioural research provides a valuable framework to investigate the among- and within-individual variation in behaviour. The animal personality theory is particularly relevant to understand and diagnostic fish welfare. It can be integrated within the nature-based welfare framework, which emphasizes the expression of species-specific behaviours and the maintenance of consistent behavioural patterns over time. Because behavioural trait such as boldness may be closely linked to other functional phenotypes, such associations reflect the broader concept of animal personality, whereby a behavioural trait can covary with another phenotypic trait to support an adaptive responses to environmental conditions. Although these relationships are both species and context dependent, they are consistently shaped by environmental conditions and environmental complexity tend to promote species specific behaviours and reduce maladaptive traits. Here we examined how structural environmental complexity shapes personality in Arctic charr and their covarying functional phenotypes, specifically growth rate and brain size. We propose that environmental complexity promotes alternative behavioural and functional phenotypes through multivariate phenotypic plasticity. We found that environmental complexity did not influence mean boldness between both treatments, but repeatability of boldness in the complex environment was remarkably consistent over a longer-term period, while estimates collapse after seven days in the plain treatment. Our findings are a clear evidence that environmental complexity foster stable behavioural trait expression and that a plain environment may suppress personality. Our results provide compelling evidence that behavioural structure and dynamics are embedded within patterns of behavioural variance. Although we found no support for behavioural covariation or associations with growth rate and brain size, we suggest that the animal personality framework may offer a valuable approach for diagnosing fish welfare issues through the partitioning of behavioural variance.

An animal's musculature must support its specific biomechanical needs, so muscle morphology and volume allocation may adapt when locomotor strategies diversify. We examined muscle size and morphology in two sister families of bombycoid moths, wild silkmoths (Saturniidae) and hawkmoths (Sphingidae), that have diverged in wingbeat frequency, wing morphology, and behavior. Although both families rely on the same muscles to power and steer flight, they may distribute muscle volume differently to prioritize distinct functions. We hypothesized that flight power muscle proportions are larger in hawkmoths and increase with wingbeat frequency, helping meet inertial power demands of high-frequency maneuverable flight. We also hypothesized that some individual muscles diverge in proportional volume and area to support distinct wing control strategies. To test our hypotheses, we took CT scans of twenty bombycoid species and quantified volumes and geometries of six flight muscle pairs. As expected, flight power muscle proportions positively correlate with wingbeat frequency and are generally greater in hawkmoths. Two of three steering muscles diverge substantially in relative volume and area between families. Most muscles exhibit greater length in silkmoths and greater cross-sectional area in hawkmoths. Finally, the dorsal oblique(DO) muscle diverges exceptionally in size and morphology, being highly developed in hawkmoths and smaller or absent in silkmoths. This unexpected difference supports the DO having an underappreciated role in flight control, possibly via shaping indirect strain propagation in the elastic thorax. We show that muscle volume distribution parallels bombycoids' divergent flight strategies, demonstrating how muscle allocation can adapt for specialized functional goals.

Specialized suction discs are functional innovations that enable fishes to attach to diverse surfaces and resist hydrodynamic forces. The adhesive discs of clingfishes (Gobiesocidae) vary in size and shape, but it is unclear how ecological factors have influenced their morphological evolution. Here we analyzed the disc and skull shape of 74 clingfish species using micro-CT scanning and 3D geometric morphometrics to investigate the role of habitat and substrate use on patterns of diversification. We also present novel comparisons of adhesive performance for 10 clingfish species. Clingfish interface directly with their environment using their adhesive discs, but we found that the disc and skulls are evolutionary integrated and share similar responses to habitat. Transitions from coastal habitats to coral reefs promoted elevated rates of evolution and morphological disparity across the body, whereas transitions to freshwater did not. Concurrently, repeated shifts from living on hard substrates to softer substrates (i.e., macroalgae and seagrass) were associated with more constrained disc shapes, convergent morphologies, and differences in adhesive performance. We propose that habitat and substrate use make complementary contributions to skeletal diversification in clingfishes, but the adhesive system requires further investigation to disentangle the complex interactions between form and function.

The shell colour polymorphism in the land snail Cepaea nemoralis is maintained by environmentally variable light intensity and predation. Previous work showed that divergence in colour polymorphism between habitat pairs of open and closed areas increased with age of the habitat. However, that study was limited to a time span of 80 years (27 snail generations). Here, we investigate shell colour divergence over habitat pair ages of 95 to 325 years. We did find an increase in evolutionary divergence of colour polymorphism with increasing age, however equilibrium could not be determined. This is possibly due to the evolutionary effect of camouflage working in opposite direction to light intensity in certain locations, consequently clouding the results. Therefore, camouflage might also be an important factor to take into account in the search for the evolutionary equilibrium of colour polymorphism in Cepaea nemoralis.

Phenotypic differences among populations can arise through heritable genetic divergence, phenotypic plasticity, or both, making it difficult to determine whether trait-environment correlations observed in nature reflect adaptive evolution. Within threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) studies, numerous document morphological differences among allopatric-, parapatric-, and even sympatric populations. These phenotypic differences among populations are often correlated with diet and lake habitat (e.g., lake size), suggesting an adaptive value to the population differences. However, many studies of ecomorphological divergence in stickleback use wild-caught stickleback, which may differ due to evolution or plasticity. Although common garden experiments have confirmed that population differences can be heritable, such experiments typically entail small numbers of populations. Consequently, we still do not know to what extent well-known trait-environment correlations in stickleback are a result of evolution. To address this gap, we reared stickleback embryos from 27 lake populations on Vancouver Island, in a laboratory environment. Morphological differences among populations persist in common-garden fish, confirming a large role for divergent evolution. These heritable differences were associated with environmental variation among lakes, implying an adaptive value. However, some well-known trait-environment relationships in stickleback did not persist in common-garden fish and may be primarily plastic.

Evolution has given rise to the diversity of life on Earth, but it can also cause species extinctions. While major extinction events are usually associated with external drivers, in this study, we show mechanistically how evolution can trigger abrupt extinction avalanches in ecological networks without any environmental change. In particular, we investigate an eco-evolutionary simulation model of a tripartite mutualistic-antagonistic network, such as a plant-pollinator-herbivore network, with additional intraguild competition. The prevalence of self-organised extinction avalanches depends on a subtle balance of the different interaction types, where antagonism and similarity-based competition are needed for initial diversification while mutualism and trait-independent competition foster evolutionarily driven extinction events. Extinction avalanches are triggered by a mutualist evolving to interact with plants that are not subject to sufficient antagonistic control. Subsequently, the mutualist, its plant partners and their main antagonist potentially outcompete the rest of the community. Our findings point out that evolutionary murder may claim many victims simultaneously and highlight the need to take different interaction types into account to gain a comprehensive understanding of the links between evolution and biodiversity in ecological communities.

Across species, changing environmental conditions are altering major phenological milestones. In seasonal environments, this can involve shifts in the timing of activity onset, growth, reproduction, and senescence; however, predicting these responses can be challenging and often requires species-specific information. In this study, we investigated phenological patterns of bumble bee colony development using observations from wild nests of two common species, Bombus griseocollis and B. impatiens. Using observations of nest traffic, we documented dates of nest-searching, peak worker activity, first gyne (new queen) production, and colony senescence over three years of field data collection. We also tested whether colony growth was density dependent, because longstanding life history models have shown that colony growth patterns determine the optimal timing of reproduction in constant environments. Here, we present a novel extension of these models, using them to infer that density-independent colony growth should be associated with extended phenology in warmer years, while density-dependent should have consistent phenology. In total, we found 79 wild nests, including 34 reproductive colonies (19 B. griseocolis and 15 B. impatiens). Bombus impatiens colonies were larger, had a longer activity period, and showed density-independent growth and later reproduction in warmer years, while B. griseocollis colonies were smaller, shorter-lived, and showed density-dependent growth and similar dates of reproduction across years. Both species had higher gyne production in warmer years. These results highlight the role of life history theory for predicting interspecific variation in phenological changes, as well as a research framework for exploring possible evolutionary mismatches of existing life histories in changing environments.

Sexual reproduction is widespread despite being less efficient than asexual reproduction. While its long-term evolutionary benefits are well recognized, it remains unclear why facultative sex, which should allow lineages to balance the advantages of both sexual and asexual reproduction, is not more common. One potential reason is that intermittent sex imposes novel costs compared to obligate sex, limiting the persistence of facultatively sexual lineages and constraining introgression. We test this possibility using the sexually polymorphic aphid parasitoid wasp Lysiphlebus fabarum. We reared offspring from females who reproduced asexually or by facultative sex for three generations (without sex after the founding generation). We genotyped F1 females to confirm facultative sex and used antennomere number, a phenotypic marker associated with reproductive mode, to test whether mixed sexual-asexual genotypes could be tracked across generations. We found multiple barriers to facultative sex. Mating did not always result in offspring with sexual-asexual genotypes, and when sex did occur, broods were usually comprised of asexually and sexually produced offspring. Additionally, lineages founded by females produced through facultative sex showed reduced fecundity compared to asexually produced broods. We saw declining frequencies of the sexual antenna phenotype in the generations after facultative sex, suggesting that genotypes generated by facultative sex are selected against. Overall, our results provide empirical support for the idea that facultative sex can impose costs that persist beyond the initial sexual event. These costs, together with low realised rates of sex, may limit long-term introgression and explain why facultative sex appears rare compared to obligate sex.

For organisms with biparental care, successful reproduction hinges on coordination between partners. Seabirds face an extreme coordination challenge because parents must schedule nest attendance on land with long-distance foraging trips at sea. We present a computational model of incubation schedules for a vulnerable seabird, the Leachs Storm-Petrel (Hydrobates leucorhous). Using only simple energetic rules and parameters, the model recapitulates natural incubation rhythms, exposes a tradeoff between parent energy and egg attendance, and predicts severe reproductive failure in harsh environments. Incubation primarily fails through "schedule breakdown" -- a single point in the season when both parents spend too long foraging and the egg dies from cold. The resilience of the developing offspring to neglect is thus a fundamental adaptation to the uncertainties of biparental care. These results raise new alarms about the indirect causes of reproductive failure in sensitive marine species and provide theoretical foundations for the evolutionary ecology of scheduling behaviors.

Animal behaviour is both innately constrained and shaped by learning. This mosaic organization has evolved in response to species-specific ecological demands and may differ between sensory modalities. Flower-visiting animals are a particularly useful system for investigating the relationship between sensory ecology and learning because they rely on multiple floral cues, particularly odour and colour, to locate food sources. However, it remains largely unexplored whether specialization on floral resources entails divergence in learning abilities across sensory modalities. Drosophila elegans is a flower-feeding species that depends heavily on floral resources throughout its life; adults spend much of their time on flowers and larvae develop on fallen flower leaves. Here, we compared odour-reward and colour-reward associative learning between the flower-feeding D. elegans and the fruit-feeding D. melanogaster. We found that, under conditions of equilibrated motivation, odour- and colour-preference, and using the same sugar reward, D. elegans exhibited poorer odour-reward learning performance but better colour-reward learning performance than D. melanogaster. These results suggest that the modality-specific eligibility of sensory information to enter into associations, known as the 'Garcia-effect' in experimental psychology, can evolve oppositely between species. This highlights the relationship between ecological specialization and mnemonic processing, and shows that biological 'intelligence' is not general.

1. Group foraging reduces the risks associated with foraging: larger groups dilute individual predation risk, allow group members to share the costs of vigilance, and provide a social structure for exchanging information about predators. The benefits of shared social information over simple safety in numbers should depend on the relationships among group members. Consequently, group composition should affect the selection of risky and safe habitats in social species. 2. We asked whether relationships among elk (Cervus canadensis) group members moving together influence their selection of risky habitats more than grouping alone. We tested three hypotheses. The familiarity hypothesis predicts that elk with close social ties are most likely to select risky habitats together. The inclusive fitness hypothesis predicts that the closest genetic relatives are most likely to select risky habitats together. The dilution hypothesis predicts that familiarity and genetic relationships do not influence habitat selection, with all group foraging benefits derived from proximity to others. 3. We used integrated Step Selection Analysis to test whether the identity of the closest group members influenced habitat selection. We tested whether the relationship of the nearest elk--either genetic or social--incentivized selection of risky habitat more than proximity to the nearest elk. 4. Group foraging clearly reduced risk, with elk more likely to select risky habitat when near others. Elk were also more likely to select risky habitats when near closer relatives, albeit with considerable variation among individuals. However, familiarity had a large and consistent effect: elk were far more likely to select risky habitats when near socially familiar group members. 5. Our results suggest that information shared within foraging groups, especially between socially familiar individuals, may lower the risks associated with habitat selection. Similarly, the benefits of reliable social information for reducing risk likely incentivizes the formation of stronger social ties within foraging groups. This positive feedback between social familiarity and habitat selection could thereby increase access to profitable habitats that are otherwise too risky, cementing what we term the social information landscape as a key driver of movement and habitat selection.